Art was the speech of the folk revival--and yet, at bottom, the folk revival did not believe in art at all. Rather, life--a certain kind of life--equaled art, which ultimately meant that life replaced it. The kind of life that equaled art was defined by suffering, deprivation, poverty, and social exclusion . . . the poor are art because they sing their lives without the false consciousness of captialism and the false desires of advertising.
. . .
When art is confused with life, it is not merely art that is lost. When art equals life there is no art, but when life equals art there are no people.
When I type "bob dylan" into the search box in my iTunes library, I come up with 551 items (including covers, duplicates, and alternate versions). And yet I know that there are vast depths out there that I haven't even heard, much less own, and my silly boasts wouldn't impress any of the long-time Dylan fans out there who have lived with his music for decades and know obsessive details about every song he's ever released. But as a salute to one of the great American artists, I hereby offer my (as of this minute and sure to change) Top 25 Bob Dylan Songs:
1. Tangled Up in Blue (Blood on the Tracks, 1975) 2. Mr. Tambourine Man (Bringing It All Back Home, 1965) 3. Like a Rolling Stone (Highway 61 Revisited, 1965) 4. Ring Them Bells (Oh Mercy, 1989) 5. A Hard Rain's A-Gonna Fall (The Freewheelin' Bob Dylan, 1963) 6. Ain't Talkin' (Modern Times, 2006) 7. Shelter from the Storm (Blood on the Tracks, 1975) 8. Visions of Johanna (Blonde on Blonde, 1966) 9. It's Alright, Ma (I'm Only Bleeding) (Bringing It All Back Home, 1965) 10. Sign on the Window (New Morning, 1970) 11. Blind Willie McTell (The Bootleg Series Vol. 1-3: Rare & Unreleased 1961-1991, rec. 1983) 12. I Was Young When I Left Home (The Bootleg Series Vol. 7: No Direction Home: The Soundtrack, rec. 1961) 13. Every Grain of Sand (Shot of Love, 1981) 14. The Times They Are A-Changin' (The Times They Are A-Changin', 1964) 15. All Along the Watchtower (John Wesley Harding, 1967) 16. I Want You (Blonde on Blonde, 1966) 17. Ballad of a Thin Man (Highway 61 Revisited, 1965) 18. Love Sick (Time Out of Mind, 1997) 19. Highway 61 Revisited (Highway 61 Revisited, 1965) 20. Stuck Inside of Mobile with the Memphis Blues Again (Blonde on Blonde, 1966) 21. Bob Dylan's 115th Dream (Bringing It All Back Home, 1965) 22. High Water (For Charley Patton) (Love & Theft, 2001) 23. Lay Lady Lay (Nashville Skyline, 1969) 24. When I Paint My Masterpiece [Demo version] (The Bootleg Series Vol. 10: Another Self Portrait, 1969-1971, rec. 1971) 25. Mississippi (Love & Theft, 2001)
Midnight Special (Nichols, 2016) Rating: 8/10 stars.
It could be a feature-length episode of The X-Files, or perhaps Escape to Witch Mountain as directed by John Carpenter. Or it may answer the question, What if Tomorrowland was good? The ending is a problem--Nichols always seems to have problems with endings--but I do not think it is an insurmountable one. Sometimes you just have to go where a movie wants to take you.
One thing I found gratifying about the film was the faces. In the Hollywood of past decades, particularly the 1970s, there were plenty of actors with weathered, craggy faces to fill roles of weathered, craggy men and women living in the American interior, or else the hard, meaty faces of blue-collar factory and dock workers from the coasts. Lee Marvin, Warren Oates, Ernest Borgnine, Charles Bronson, Strother Martin, Harry Dean Stanton, John Cazale--the list goes on. Among actresses, we might mention Sissy Spacek, Shelley Duvall, or Talia Shire--but the demands on beauty have always been much greater for actresses. These faces were memorable because directors then knew how to use them, knew that performers like that brought an authenticity you can't fake to their films. Such faces have died out in modern Hollywood. To a certain extent they have died down in American society, what with good plumbing and acne medication and all (most of the performers I just listed lived through the Great Depression, and a few fought in World War 2).
Jeff Nichols is one of the few directors in current American movies who seems to go looking for such faces, and even if what he finds can't equal the past, he still manages to create a convincing rural American through face and texture alone. Here he casts Michael Shannon, Joel Edgerton, Adam Driver, and Sam Shepard (not to mention character actors like Bill Camp and David Jensen), and even manages to transform Kirsten Dunst into utterly convincing Pennsylvania Dutch motherhood. Such actors feel like blue collar America in a way so many others do not. And when one takes a wider lay of the land and sees character actors like Shea Wigham, Jason Clarke, Ben Mendelsohn, and Scoot McNairy gaining in prominence and getting cast all over the place, why, it's almost enough to make one optimistic about Hollywood.
Lemonade (Knowles et al., 2016) Rating: 8/10 stars.
Watching this, I'm reminded of the review I read when Watch the Throne came out, which said the big thing that distinguished Kanye from Jay-Z was--humility. Paradoxically true then, obvious now.
Love to see the references to everything from Ganja & Hess to David Lynch--Beyonce is really stretching herself, and this is going to lead a lot of people in a lot of new directions in their movie-watching. I put Daughters of the Dust on my watchlist like 9 months ago and I still haven't gotten around to it, and now I feel like I'm late to the party or something! I gotta get on that. [UPDATE: I did, and it's wonderful.] Beyonce reads Warsan Shire's poetry with rich and biting intonation that lends suspense to every line; I suspect these poems sound better aloud than read on a page. The synergy between the music and the images is remarkable, with both visual and musical compositions striking and memorable.
I do have a few caveats, though: I remain a little uncomfortable with the way Beyonce, surely the second most powerful black woman in the country (maybe the world?), equates her personal problems with a cheating husband to the larger historical oppression of all poor and enslaved African-American women. But the usual identity politics activists don't seem bothered by this point at all, and I'm a lot more uncomfortable with ever coming off more politically puritanical that that sort of commentator on such issues, so I guess I'll just shut up about it. On more aesthetic grounds, let's get one thing clear: as much as this apes Malick throughout (in ways so obvious I'm not even going to list them), it's not "better than" or even (IMO) "as good as" Malick. The editing here is nowhere near as radical, the interplay between music, voice, and image is nowhere near as complex, and the artistic risk and ambition is not as great. Knight of Cups is in a different order of magnitude--and has more to say about the world we live in today besides.
(Not to mention the pacing problems--this is still a pop album first, experimental film second.)
But still, this is pretty darn good, and way better than I expected.
Odd, twisty little Las Vegas-set crime movie. Twisty not in the sense that it effectively manipulates the audience, but in the way it keeps shifting gears and tones in unusual/surprising ways. After opening with a fake-out confrontation that posits Burt Reynolds as a neanderthal attempted-rapist who gets beaten up by a weak-chinned but righteous boyfriend, the movie then reveals him as a weird cross between lovable loser and unbeatable hitman, and his various jobs include playacting, gambling, extortion, bodyguarding, and fight training (all taken in a quixotic attempt to move to Italy and retire).
The action scenes are chopped up into shards of slow-motion bloody violence in a way that isn't really successful, and the whole thing is alternately gritty and goofy, but it can still surprise with moments of poetry. I'm thinking here of the scene where Reynolds and his rich-kid trainee/employer bond while gazing out on the vividly lit Vegas strip from a balcony, and Reynolds admits:
-"I've never been here when the sun's up."
-"I have a feeling it turns into the real world then."